Well, you gotta figure, it won't be memorable to her per se, so whatever you do get her has to make for a great "photo op". I currently have at home a 2 year old and a 1 1/2 month old. My local fire dept has a program where you bring a wrapped toy to them and make a donation, and Santa delivers the present to your home on Christmas Eve during a certain set time frame...ON a fire truck! that, i thought, will make a great photo op, even if the little one won't remember it. At least she'll see in the photos that Santa delivered her a present when she was a newborn! I don't think it's so much what item is given to the baby, but the WAY she recieves it. Like, who's lap is she in while opening the gift, how you can set her and "it" up in a photo... is it something she can wear, like a Santa hat, something that will look good in a photo, that's probalby the best you can hope for! While I was in labor with my now 2 year old, I crocheted her a santa claus hat. She was born 3 days before Christmas in 2004. So many of her baby newborn pics she's wearing that hat. If you can't crochet, you can always put one together, just get red felt, cut out the shape of a hat, whip stitch it together or just use glue! make a white rim of the hat out of white felt, and make a pom pom, that's kinda easy! And it makes for some memorable pictures, nothing cuter than a little baby in a Christmas santa hat :)