Whiney Baby

Updated on August 27, 2007
M.S. asks from Trenton, NJ
11 answers

My son is almost 11 months old and is SUCH A WHINER/SCREAMER. (He is screaming right now and I am ignoring him) He was born with just about the most horrible colic that his ped ever witnessed so he is used to being held and consoled a great deal. He also has a bad case of widespread eczema so he is uncomfortable. The only thing I cannot understand is that he does not scream and yell in daycare AT ALL. His teachers and director have only good things to say about his behavior. I have sncuk in and watched him from afar. He smiles and coos with the other children but tries my patients when I am home with him. I explain to him that screaming and yelling is not the way to get things and if he screams mommy will put him down(baring that he is not suffering from eczema or in pain from teething)I am very consistent with this practice. It is frustrating because he is stuck to me like glue when I am home with him and I can get very little accomplished. Help!

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

Featured Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

A.M.

answers from New York on

I have the same problem. My son is also 11 mos and is the biggest whiner ever. My 3 year daughter was never like this so I was not too prepared for it. What I actually do, is I will hold him for a little bit and tell him that he does not need to worry because mama was there. Then I will sit with him with a toy for a few minutes and get him involved with the toy. He likes blocks and opening books. Once he is playing, I do what I need to do. I let him play where he can see me. It's working so far for me.

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

Y.A.

answers from New York on

Try wearing him in a baby carrier or a sling. He needs your closeness, don't deny him that, especially if he is in daycare all day. Babies have needs, it's ok to need Mommy and her hugs. Baby carrier would free your arms and will enable you to do more in the house.

good luck!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.S.

answers from New York on

M.,

in light of your other request this one makes perfect sense. babies are like enormous mirrors... they pick up on and mirror back our emotional states. i have no doubt that your baby is sensing his mommy's internal struggle. my advice: take care of your needs, get rest, get support from friends/ family... a happy mommy makes for a happy baby

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.C.

answers from New York on

I am sorry you are having such a hard time. I have been working with children for over 17 years and just had my 1st one. I had a child act that way at a daycare I worked at once, it was so bad they were ready to ask her to leave because the teachers couldn't deal with it. But I changed her and she was a great child after that.
First , let's try to mke him more comfortable. try bathing him in Aveeno bath and shower oil (dark blue top)(ask your Doc first)it's about $8-9 but worth it. I've had skin problems all my life and this stuff and all other Aveeno products have totally saved me.and find a good cream for after bath- I love CUREL.
Second,If he had colic and is used to you holding him, first, remember you must have comforted him a great deal and when he is with you he wants to feel that great love SO- when he is quiet or acting appropriately give him a hug or whatever physical touching he likes but don't pick him up! get down to his level and hug and kiss him talk soothingly and tell him how proud you are of him but as soon as he starts to cry or cling to you turn your head away and don't look at him or talk to him, even walk away. but as soon as he stops look at him and smile and talk and hug again.
The point is to reward that good behavior with what he wants, It's fine to ignore him when he's crying IF you give love when he's not.
REMEMBER as a colic baby he was taught that when he cried- he got held and loved- you need to retrain him. It's not his fault- try to be patient.
Good luck- I know it's hard.
S.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

N.D.

answers from New York on

Hi M.,
I have two boys three and a half and 15 months. My younger one does the same thing and keeps sticking to me when I am around. But I am not worried because with the experience with the elder one I know that it is a phase and will passby. Most of the kids start doing that when they are 8-12 months of age and stop stop around 24-30 months of age. He is just insecure about you and wants to be with you all the time. He is scared that you would leave him. Try not to ignore him when he does that or he will get frustrated and aggressive. Be with him and give him a lot of love to make him feel secure and comforted. Keep telling him that you love him a lot. Believe me it is just a phase. As your son grows and gets more independent this thing will reduce and will eventually stop. Just keep patience.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

A.C.

answers from New York on

M.,

Hi, my name is A.. I have a 2 yr. old. My son didn't have colic, but we all have eczema. Make sure he's getting enough calcium, magnesium, and zinc in his diet. This is something I found out about after I gave birth and mine exploded. Magnesium and zinc seem to be the most critical. Most people who are ashmatics and have eczema are missing these two substances the most. Once I got more in my system, it went away. Also, I use a brand of lotion called "That Soap Guy" out of New hampshire, all natural, and it helped clear up my son's skin. I learned late in life that eating red meat and drinking too much milk in combo with all the chemicals in traditional beauty products, including lotion, aggrevates skin problems, as I found this summer with all the suntan lotion we were using.

With the behavior, I see this with my friends kids who feel they don't get enough attention, and with my own son when I'm not paying attention. I have to keep him on my lap at all times if I'm on the computer and just keep the Wiggles going and usually he's fine. I get a lot done that way. Or find something on Youtube, for example, someone reading a story he likes, and put that on while you work. Also try one of those snugglies or wraps and wear that when you're working. The physical closeness seems to calm him (my son)while keeping your hands free.

Good luck!

A.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.B.

answers from New York on

M......I can soooo relate! It's the age as far as the separation thing. Unforturnately in some cases it may last a little longer, so hang in there. Just be very very consistent and let him help you do things around the house. Granted, it will take longer but you will get it done and he will feel useful and can still have your attention. My kids help me clean with a sponge, have a play vacuum, help with laundry, etc.. I realize he's probably not walking yet so it's tough. He's learning about power,independence, cause and effect, and such. Stay strong and it will change just in time for something else to start!! Wish I could be more helpful!

Kelley

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

Q.F.

answers from New York on

M.,

Hi, i can relate somewhat. My daughter is a big whiner, but doesn't have the eczema, my friend's son has it bad though...she says that the dr. had given her some kind of cream for him, and it didn't really work all that well. she said that instead, she pretty much covers him in a petroleum jelly like product. the sun is GREAT for eczema, unfortunately, heat is REALLY BAD! as soon as it starts getting cooler out, you should do what you can to have him outside as much as possible. until then you need to try and get him out in the sun during any possible cool points of the day (even if it has to be early in the morning as soon as he gets up). try not to bathe him too often, especially not in really warm water. and if you can, put anything cold/cool on him to help ease the pain...if she's shopping and he starts itching, she takes something from the frozen foods and puts it on him to help soothe the pain.
as for the whines and screams...keep doing what you're doing. console him when he's not feeling good, but if he's fine, put him down when he starts whining and keep telling him that this behavior just isn't accepted. when my daughter starts i'll pick her up and tell her how much i love her, but that she needs to learn and play by herself. yeah, she likes to just sit on my lap and watch her morning (educational) cartoons...but if i just sit on the floor with her and get her preoccupied with playing, i can sneak off and do some cleaning.
don't listen to people who tell you that you need to be a mother when you're with him...YES, you HAVE to be his mother, and you HAVE to spend your time with him!!! BUT...you do need to get things done too. try to get as much done as possible when he's sleeping, but what you can't get done then, do while he's playing. it takes some time, but by when my daughter was not much older then he is now...she started going off and playing on her own. but for some reason she just wouldn't do play on her own (or let me leave the room w/out her freaking out...even if she could still see me in the other room) until she was able to walk without help. the reason he probably acts so well when at daycare and not at home is because he was colic and is used to you pretty much dropping everything for him (because of the colic and wanting to soothe him) and he's used to it, but no one at daycare did that, so he doesn't expect it from them. kids have the amazing ability to pick out the saps that they can twist around their lil finger and play them until they get what they want. unfortunately mommy is usually the biggest sap of all (i KNOW i am!!!) even if you can't stand it, and it drives you crazy, you don't want to hear them whining and screaming...you want them to be happy and can't help but give in to see them happy. once i learned that i just tried to always turn her attention to something else. she's MUCH better now...the only time i really have the problem is when she's really tired, sick, or teething (thank god that she's almost done with that!)
if you need to clean, and can't seem to get him to play on his own. you can try what my mother does (which SOMETIMES works for me). you can try to give him something to clean while you clean. my mother likes to just tell her to help and put things away, while a friend of mine likes to tell her nephew to help her clean, and hands him a sponge, and he'll just go around and wipe everything down...even the walls lol! when i get her to help me, she'll put some things away, but she likes to hand me things. i may have to repeat myself a ton of times, but she gets all excited and runs for what i ask her to get, and runs back to me with it with a huge smile...then i clap my hands and say "oh, you're such a big helper for mommy...THANK YOU!" doing this not only gets them to start learning to clean (and making cleaning as fun as possible works the best), it also helps get done what YOU need to do while spending time with your child!
if you can't do that just yet (if he's not really walking yet) don't worry, just be patient and try to get him to play on his own for a little bit at a time until you can try getting him to follow you and help out (once starts to walk, if he's not already). also, i know people say that children so young shouldn't watch tv, but if you find something educational to watch, you can put him down to watch something (like sesame street, little einsteins, mickey mouse club house, etc.) and this way he's not only preoccupied with that, he's also learning! i do that in the mornings. it's MY background noise (since i don't like things completely quiet) and her learning, and distraction while she eats, plays and i clean or do what i have to do. once i'm done with as much as i can get done at that time, i try to sit down with her and continue teaching whatever she learned while watching tv, then it's nap time and i continue doing what i have to do. well, i HOPE i helped even just a bit...GOOD LUCK!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

A.A.

answers from Philadelphia on

i know what your going through my daughter is 4 1/2 and still acts like that. daycare teachers love her but she is horrible at home. it is a common thing. you just have to keep following through even when he is having problems. when he is of course really bad console but you have to follow through at all times. maybe if you do it now you wont have my problem. i have to deal with both grandparents and dad all in different houses. i am single so mine will not end completely EVER! good luck

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

N.P.

answers from Philadelphia on

Marissa, I too can relate to what you are going through. My 9 month old is doing the same thing right now as we speak. I am a stay at home mom and I get it all day long. It can be very trying. My husband will take him and play with him for about a 1/2 hour everyday so I can just get my sanity back. All he has to do is see me and he starts up though. There is nothing wrong with letting him play by himself while you try to get a couple things done. As a former teacher, the children who spent quality alone time were much more well rounded. He will not have problems in th future as someone in a previous response said. He will be fine. You just need to walk away and take a five minute breather on occasion to get your sanity back. Hang in there. It will get better.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

B.C.

answers from New York on

Instead of trying to get things accomplished when you are home with your son, maybe you should be spending your time being a mother to him. He is whining because he needs your attention and if you don't start giving him the attention he needs he will grow up to be a miserable person who had to constantly strive to feel loved.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions

Related Searches